
A photo circulated online in 2024 shows a Western man standing beside a roadside traffic light, holding a sign reading 'Help to Survive' to ask for money.
Being of Western appearance, my mind turned to the question of why he was asking locals for money in order for him to travel around the world.
It seems to have become a topic again recently.
People from various countries are traveling the world as backpackers. And rather than having savings and earning money as they go, a number of those travelers are standing on street corners in places like Ho Chi Minh City, asking for donations so they may continue their adventures and journeys around the world.
The world has a name for them now: begpackers. And I find this to be offensive in so many areas.
This is not something I'm imagining. Foreign tourists have been photographed begging on Phu Quoc island, and in 2017 it got so bad that the tourism chief of Kien Giang province publicly reminded everyone that street begging is not allowed in Vietnam, and that the rule applies to foreigners as well as locals.
Another provincial official put it even more bluntly: foreigners who come here to work need a legitimate labor contract, and street begging is not considered a job.

A female tourist meditates on a sidewalk in Phu Quoc while begging for money in August 2017. Photo: Tuoi Tre
Historically, this has been a very normal practice. Over centuries, travelers have leant on the kindness of local communities in order to get from A to B.
But the purpose of travel was very different. They were not backpackers, and they were not doing it for pure enjoyment, or for the pleasure of having the adventure of traveling around the world and living a great life at the expense of other people.
Back in those days, traveling was a necessity. People traveled to get work, to seek help, to give help and to drive the country forward in times of extreme poverty.
This is a very different situation.
While some may see this as an acceptable practice, my personal opinion is that it is offensive to both the Vietnamese and expat communities here in Vietnam and in Ho Chi Minh City.
These young people believe they have a right to lean on the kindness of others for their own personal gain and pleasure. And that's not right.
Kindness, generosity and charity come, in my mind, through the bastion of need and personal development. Adventure tourism and backpacking fit neither category.
Think about who is actually being asked to pay.
The average Vietnamese worker earns about VND9 million a month, roughly US$349. Many of the people riding past those Western backpackers' begging signs earn far less.
When a young Westerner asks them to fund the next leg of a holiday, he is asking someone on a few hundred dollars a month to subsidise a lifestyle most of them will never be able to afford.

This photo, which has recently circulated on social media, purportedly shows two foreign travelers holding a handwritten sign in Vietnamese reading: "Hello! We are travelers around the world from Belarus. No money. Please support to continue going thank you!"
Sitting behind this is a secondary issue. The current laws in Vietnam restrict foreigners from obtaining any employment unless they fit very strict categories.
It was well known that there was once a time when backpackers would come to a country and work as English teachers for three to six months, earning enough to carry on their adventures.
Those loopholes and opportunities have changed as the standards of English education have grown over the past decade or two.
Indeed, the recent circular from the education department makes it even harder for young people without qualifications to get work teaching English anywhere in Vietnam.
But the lack of opportunity does not make this practice acceptable. It shows a lack of responsibility, a lack of personal planning and an apathy towards the community, where people believe they have a right to take money from people who are clearly not deserving of losing it.
And if someone is truly stranded, broke and in trouble, the answer is not a cardboard sign on a busy road. People need to go to their embassy for help. But these sign holders do not share the desperation of those during COVID-19. They are selfish grifters abusing the kindness of the local community.
I will not give money to these people under any circumstances. I am repulsed by their activity.
So I call on everyone, Vietnamese and expat alike, to make it known that begging for money on the street in order to travel is not acceptable from tourists or foreigners of any kind in Vietnam. It must stop.
Keep your money in your pocket. Put it in the hands of the people who genuinely need it, the elderly lottery seller, the family that lost everything in the floods, the local charity feeding kids in your own locality.
We must look after those in need, and those who must get support in our community, before we facilitate rich kids traveling around the world.
Ray Kuschert / Tuoi Tre News Contributor
Link nội dung: https://news.tuoitre.vn/begpackers-why-i-wont-fund-your-gap-year-on-the-streets-of-saigon-103261122193453188.htm