As Vietnam steps up efforts to fulfil its Net Zero commitment by 2050, carbon credit markets and green finance have become topics of unprecedented interest. The Saigon Times spoke with Assoc. Prof. Dr. Nguyen Hong Quan, director of the Institute for Circular Economy Development Research (ICED) at Vietnam National University–Ho Chi Minh City, about key concepts, opportunities for businesses, and the pilot “Living Lab” model at VNU-HCM.
Public investment is a prerequisite The Saigon Times: Concepts such as “carbon credits,” “carbon markets,” and “carbon exchanges” are being mentioned frequently in the media. Yet many people — including policymakers — still find them confusing. Could you explain the basics for our readers? - Nguyen Hong Quan: In the course of global and Vietnamese development, reducing waste and greenhouse gas emissions has become an urgent requirement. One key parameter related to greenhouse gases is carbon emissions. Depending on each country, regulations are set on how much each business is allowed to emit. Vietnam, for example, already has regulations on greenhouse gas inventory. Beyond a certain threshold — measured in tons of carbon emissions per year — enterprises are required to conduct inventories and implement emission-reduction measures. So what is a carbon credit? Under current regulations, if we reduce one ton of CO2, that is equivalent to earning one carbon credit. There are currently two mechanisms: compliance (mandatory) and voluntary. Under the mandatory mechanism, enterprises are subject to emission caps. If they are unable to immediately transition their technology to meet reduction requirements, they must purchase carbon credits from other entities that have surplus reductions, in order to offset their shortfall. Under the voluntary mechanism, even if not required to do so, enterprises may choose to contribute to sustainable development goals or align with their own ESG strategies by proactively purchasing additional credits. These credits can be traded on either voluntary or compliance carbon markets. Let me add that ESG, standing for Environmental, Social and Governance, is a set of criteria used to assess sustainability, a company’s impact on society, and non-financial factors, rather than focusing solely on short-term profits. ESG helps evaluate risks, opportunities and corporate reputation. Does this market operate like other commodity markets? Can buyers and sellers be businesses, or even countries? - Carbon credits can be traded between businesses, and also between countries. At the national level, for example, governments such as Switzerland or Japan have international commitments to reduce carbon emissions. They may purchase credits for the government through designated organizations. In such cases, relevant ministries — for instance Vietnam’s Ministry of Agriculture and Environment — would coordinate the procedures. In the past, Vietnam sold forest carbon credits from the North Central region through the World Bank. At the corporate level, businesses can buy and sell credits domestically and internationally through carbon markets. Some Vietnamese companies have already sold credits on the global carbon market, particularly in renewable energy. However, we still lack comprehensive statistics and assessments of these activities, which I believe represents a gap that needs attention. Could speculation occur in this market? Some have suggested the emergence of “carbon banks” to invest in and stockpile carbon credits. What is your view? - Honestly, I don’t have a very clear picture of the concept of a “bank” in this context. However, investment or even speculation in carbon credits could be appropriate. To encourage market development, there must be buyers and sellers. In some cases, enterprises hold credits but cannot find buyers, or their ability to sell on international markets is limited due to complex measurement, reporting and verification procedures. In such situations, private investors or even governments could step in to invest or purchase credits to provide support. This investment helps share risks with businesses and encourages them to pursue a green transition. Once purchased, carbon credits can be “banked” for future use. They may be applied to Vietnam’s NDC—its nationally determined contribution under the 2015 Paris Agreement to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and adapt to climate change—or later resold to other domestic companies in need, for example exporters seeking to comply with the EU’s CBAM mechanism. In my view, without the role of investment—especially public investment to stimulate the market—the current nascent market would be very difficult to operate. Whether this market is healthy or not hinges on a key issue: the credibility of carbon credits? – Yes, I understand your point. Indeed, without a Monitoring – Reporting – Verification (MRV) system, there can be no carbon credits—or if they do exist, they can only be sold at very low prices due to insufficient credibility. In today’s global market, carbon credit prices vary widely, ranging from just a few U.S. dollars to hundreds of U.S. dollars. High or low value depends on how transparent and accurate the measurement system is, as well as on the intrinsic value of the credits generated. For example, carbon credits from mangroves and seagrass ecosystems are currently highly valued and are often referred to as blue carbon. The more detailed and transparent the MRV system, the greater the value of the credits. It is not simply a matter of declaring that credits exist. To create a high-quality “product” with strong trading value, effective digital transformation is essential. Data must be digitized to ensure transparency. Measurement requirements may vary depending on buyers’ expectations, but the process must be substantive; it cannot merely exist “on paper.” Anyone could generate carbon credits in the future? It is known that you and your colleagues have proposed a “Living Lab” model at Vietnam National University–Ho Chi Minh City (VNU-HCM) aimed at developing a carbon-credit urban model? – Fundamentally, a Living Lab is entirely different from traditional, closed laboratories. It is a space where models can be demonstrated in real-world conditions, rather than being confined to calculations in a lab. It is an open innovation ecosystem operating within real-life contexts, user-centered, and based on a “quadruple helix” model involving the State, businesses, scientists, and the community. We propose VNU-HCM as the pilot site because it possesses all the characteristics of a “miniature city.” With an area of more than 650 hectares and a large, multidisciplinary scale, it is broad enough to test complex policies while still being compact enough to manage risks.
If EVN introduces incentives for households to save energy or install rooftop solar systems, even if each household saves only a small amount, multiplying that across tens of millions of households becomes a case of “small contributions adding up to something big.” Just imagine if only 30–50% of households in HCMC participated, the resulting emissions reduction would be enormous.
At that point, the State, through EVN or other enterprises, could collect and aggregate these small-scale electricity savings and convert them into carbon credits. Instead of individual households being unable to sell credits due to their small scale, EVN would act as a representative aggregator to verify and trade them. This is an accumulation mechanism for credits.
The remaining challenge lies in technology requirements. To sell these credits, EVN would need to develop structured projects and transparent measurement systems based on digitized data to demonstrate actual electricity savings compared with a baseline. Without properly designed projects, these efforts would only contribute to national targets and could not be monetized.
This shows that the carbon market is not solely the domain of large industrial players. In the future, individual households and even individuals could become credit sellers if appropriate mechanisms are in place.
In urban areas such as HCMC, as mentioned, credits generated from households planting trees, installing rooftop solar, practicing energy conservation, and sorting recyclable waste all contribute to overall emissions reductions. The prerequisite is a clear system for evaluation, recording, and reporting.
In rural areas, credits could come from rice fields. The “one million hectares of high-quality rice” program is being pioneered in the Mekong Delta. Farmers participating in the program change cultivation practices—reducing fertilizer use and adopting alternate wetting and drying irrigation. These practices reduce greenhouse gas emissions, especially methane. The dual benefit is that farmers lower input costs such as fertilizer and water while earning additional income from selling carbon credits generated from their own fields.
HCMC is developing an international financial center. In your view, what role does the carbon market play in this picture?
– I think this is a tremendous opportunity for green finance, with the carbon credit market serving as one of the key pillars of the International Financial Center in HCMC.
According to current plans, HCMC will pilot the national carbon market before it is rolled out nationwide. Within the context of an international financial center, the market’s position will be significantly strengthened, enabling it to attract greater resources. I am very optimistic that this will be one of the crucial solutions to the challenge of mobilizing capital for green projects in the foreseeable future.
Reported by Quoc Ngoc